The Dangerous Optimism of Climate Scenarios: The Reality Lost Between RCP 8.5 and RCP 2.6
In April 2026, the IPCC formally declared that RCP 8.5, one of the most debated scenarios in climate science, is no longer realistic. According to the report, the rapid growth of renewable energy and the partial transformation brought about by climate policies have made the highest-emissions pathway increasingly unlikely. For many observers, the announcement was reassuring news. Yet there is reason to be cautious about that sense of relief. The same report also quietly acknowledged that RCP 2.6—the pathway designed to keep global warming below 2°C—may no longer be realistic either. Taken together, these two statements reveal a profound contradiction at the heart of climate science today. The retirement of RCP 8.5 is partly welcome news. Coal consumption is unlikely to rise to the levels assumed by that scenario, and renewable energy has expanded much faster than many expected. However, it is important to distinguish between emissions pathways and temperature outcomes. The fact that RCP...